What does it really mean to "play keyboard"?

[BKN4691]

This is inspired by a recently resurfaced old thread from one of our "one-and-done" members that was replied to 13 years late

The late response touched on this somewhat, but what I thought was really interesting was the OP's comment "there is no good keyboard teacher available so that is why I decided to learn piano".

I'm sure most of us here recognize there are pretty big technique differences between playing piano, organ, arranger keyboard, synthesizer, etc., not to mention the various styles/genres. And also that there are a lot of variations of what is described as a "keyboard" (arranger, workstation, stage piano, etc.). I imagine when an aspiring player first states that they want to "learn to play keyboard" they're likely envisioning something like they've seen/heard from Yes, ELP, Pink Floyd, Dream Theater, etc. I think if they were specifically looking to learn to play piano they would probably state that. But otherwise: who knows?

So I'm curious: If someone says they want to learn to "play keyboard", or they say "I play the keyboard", what pops into your head, or what questions do you have for them?

P.S. If a discussion already exists on this subject, feel free to point me to it or have it merged.

 

[happyrat1]

I'm self taught and play mostly by ear. Lots of early blues musicians had no formal training at all, but to me learning music is simply learning to speak music with your fingers. It's a matter of training your fingers to play the patterns that make up the riffs and melodies of a popular song.

What I'm saying is that there is not simply one useful method to learn a new language.

Like learning Spanish or French, fluency comes with practical application.

 

[Biggles]

What they said /\

 

[Bouncingogre]

I was taught piano from an early age, but transitioned to organ at around 14.
I now play Arranger keyboards, and love the versatility of them.
I play from sheet music and by ear. I won't buy a new book of music until I can play all the numbers in the book I'm currently playing.
Lots and lots of practice is the key. All instruments have their own characteristics, and even how you touch the keys is important.
I aim to play for at least 2 hours a day, but often much longer. I still love the sheer size, sound and challenge of an organ. Then you get to give your feet a workout too!
I like Gary's description. It's learning to speak music with your fingers. So true.
As an old guy, playing an instrument is very satisfying. There's always something new to learn, which keeps the brain active.