Split Horn Sound

Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
1,727
Reaction score
619
scott, what he asked for was the ability to hear a three note chord, each note playing a different instrument. That's exactly the RESULT I would get with what i described above, the only difference is that i dont have to play the entire 3 note chord, instead i play a single note but achieve the same result ;). As the poster asked "..Got any ideas on how to make this happen? .." Well, my solution makes it happen but with just playing a single note. Think out of the box dude....

P.S. You're welcome.....
No, what he asked for was the behavior of a Fantom G with the brass card, where you could play any chord you wanted, and each note would be assigned a different instrument in the ensemble. Read the thread, dude! :) Especially Doug Laniere's post #5, where he makes very clear what he's looking for. And watch the video.

I'm not saying that what you suggested isn't a cool alternate way to do something similar, but it is not what he really asked for. The idea isn't to play moving identical-interval triads (or switchable triads with a helper switch), it's to play whatever chords you want, with whatever intervals you want, as you would normally play them, and have them voiced with the different horns playing the different parts. Regardless of which inversions of chords you choose, or whether the chords are voiced close or over a 2-hand distance, etc. It's cool. And very few boards can do it.
 
Joined
Apr 4, 2012
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
769
And very few boards can do it.
We know and he knows that his board doesn't have the ability to do it identically the way the Fantom G does it because the functionality doesn't exist in his keyboard. Knowing those facts he then asked this:

" ... Please explain how to do this... 3 note chord =

1) High note played by trumpet only
2) Middle note played by tenor sax only
3) Low note played by trombone only

Got any ideas on how to make this happen? .."

There are only two answers:

1) It can't be done on your keyboard like the Fantom series because your board doesn't have that functionality OR ...
2) Here's an alternative way of getting you there .....

Capiche?
 
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
1,727
Reaction score
619
We know and he knows that his board doesn't have the ability to do it identically the way the Fantom G does it because the functionality doesn't exist in his keyboard. Knowing those facts he then asked this:

" ... Please explain how to do this... 3 note chord =

1) High note played by trumpet only
2) Middle note played by tenor sax only
3) Low note played by trombone only

Got any ideas on how to make this happen? .."

There are only two answers:

1) It can't be done on your keyboard like the Fantom series because your board doesn't have that functionality OR ...
2) Here's an alternative way of getting you there .....

Capiche?

The first thing he asked was whether any current keyboard could do it. The answer was Genos.

The later "please explain how to do this" you're quoting was in response to someone saying it could probably be done on a Krome (i.e. in context, he was asking how to do it on a Krome). It's obviously perfectly reasonable for you to essentially reply that, you don't know about how to do it on a Krome, but here's how you could do it on a Kurzweil. The thing is, what you explained does NOT do what he asked for, for multiple reasons. First is because of a line you omitted from your quote, which I will re-insert here, in italics...

Please explain how to do this...

Single unison note = all 3 horns play the same note

3 note chord =

1) High note played by trumpet only
2) Middle note played by tenor sax only
3) Low note played by trombone only

Got any ideas on how to make this happen?

though that could be created separately, using more zones (albeit likely at the expense of playability, esp. single-hand playability). Second, the functionality he is looking for is not necessarily limited to playing only major triads (or button-switchable major or minor triads), as you described. Third, as he explained it in that post and more explicitly in his other posts, he is looking to actually play the chords (e.g. press three keys to get the three notes, press one key to get one note, presumably press other numbers of keys to get other numbers of notes... IOW, play "normally", rather than triggering chords from single keys). That is related to the first two I mentioned, since it addresses those limitations... i.e. playing "normally" means you can play any intervals you want at any time, and shift seamlessly between single-note lines and chords. Assigning chords to keys doesn't do these things.

Again, I'm not saying that what you suggested wasn't useful! I'm just saying that you misunderstood the goal when you started by saying, "I'm assuming that you mean play one key on a keyboard and hear a 3-note chord, each note a different instrument......" -- No, that's not AT ALL what he meant. That's why that was the part of your post I quoted.

But sure, even though it's not what he meant, what you suggested is another way to achieve a similar effect in some situations, so it's an approach worth mentioning. (And it is something that could be done on many boards... including Krome.) Just because I pointed out that your assumption that his desire was to hear a 3 note chord by playing a single note on the keyboard missed the mark, that doesn't mean I think your suggestion didn't have value. Assuming he doesn't want to buy a Genos, any suggestions for alternate ways of getting, if not the same thing, then at least something of a similar effect in some situations, could possibly be useful. Like your suggestion, and the one that Biggles posted in post #13.

Comprendez?
 
Joined
Sep 6, 2017
Messages
6,100
Reaction score
3,366
Location
Lancashire, UK.
Doug is obviously very interested in your response as he has not been on the forum since last year.

Hence surely it is a moot point as to what he did or did not seek by way of advice.
 
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
1,727
Reaction score
619
Last year, okay, but also, only about two months ago! ;-)

Anyway, I didn't mean to get into a whole big thing here, I just came back to the thread to correct/update one of my own old comments in case anyone was following, and saw what was (at the time) the last post which prompted me to also clarify what looked to me like a misunderstanding of the goal while I was there. But yeah, that horse is probably sufficiently beaten.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
14,514
Messages
90,552
Members
13,437
Latest member
misty

Latest Threads

Top